• Rose and Rose Solicitors

Need overcomes equality claim in divorce settlement



With new guidance having been issued regarding the interpretation of 'need' for the purpose of financial settlements on divorce, a recent case shows how the courts have been moving away from a rigid adherence to the principle of 'equality' in the division of assets.


It involved a wealthy couple who had in excess of £10 million in assets when they commenced divorce proceedings 14 years after they married. The ex-husband argued that his former wife's claim for a half share of the assets was not appropriate because he already owned their care home business when they married.


He claimed the business was worth an estimated £5.6 million when they married. His ex-wife claimed that it was almost valueless and was only restored to a solid financial footing by virtue of her hard work. She argued that a 50:50 split of assets would be fair, since their wealth had been built up jointly and claimed that her former husband had promised her a 50:50 split of assets.


The Family Court did not accept her argument and decided instead that the division should be based on her appropriate level of need. The judge ruled that the ex-wife should receive £1 million to provide housing and £1.3 million to provide income. 


Please note we are unable to offer legal aid.

If you have difficulty with mobility we can arrange to see you outside the office where there is ease of access or even at your home 

© Rose & Rose. All rights reserved. Registered Office: The Riverside Centre, 40 High Street, Kingston upon Thames, KT1 1HL 

London, Tower Hill: 1 St Katharine's Way, St Katharine's & Wapping, London E1W 1UN

Rose & Rose LLP t/a Rose & Rose (Company no. OC363353)

VAT Number: GB 928 5154 08

Authorised and Regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)

SRA ID: 559162